Why do sovereign wealth funds terminate external managers?
Short answer: Sovereign wealth funds terminate external managers for several specific operational and performance reasons. The IFSWF identifies changing fund objectives, continued poor returns, loss of trust, and organizational changes at an asset manager as key reasons to consider ending a mandate[1]. Institutional actions show that regulatory penalties and client overcharging also lead funds to cancel agreements with their external managers[2].
Primary reasons for ending external manager mandates
Sovereign wealth funds review their relationships with external asset management firms on an ongoing basis. According to the International Forum of Sovereign Wealth Funds, funds consider terminating a manager when fund objectives change over time[1]. Sustained underperformance by an asset manager is another main factor that causes an institution to review and end a mandate[1].
Trust between a sovereign fund and an external asset firm is essential to their business relationship. The IFSWF states that trust concerns are grounds for sovereign wealth funds to consider ending a mandate[1]. Changes within the external firm itself also trigger mandate terminations[1]. These internal manager developments include changes to investment strategies, key personnel departures, and general organizational shifts[1].
Mandates, benchmarks, and commercial terms
Regulatory enforcement actions against asset managers can directly cause sovereign wealth funds to end existing relationships. For example, the NPRF terminated its indexed equity mandate with State Street Global Advisors after the UK FCA fined State Street for overcharging the NPRF and other clients[2]. This action illustrates how operational issues and fee misconduct lead to mandate cancellations[2].
Different sovereign funds approach their external manager mandates and benchmark structures with distinct requirements. ADIA provides external managers with very precise mandates along with tailored benchmarks[3]. ADIA also often negotiates management fees that are around half the rates paid by other institutions[3]. In contrast, the Future Fund seeks to be benchmark-unaware across its portfolio[4]. The Future Fund faces challenges when seeking external managers who share this approach and do not focus on traditional benchmarks[4].
"Reasons to terminate Investment objectives change such that the strategy is no longer suitable The manager underperforms the benchmark over a meaningful period of time Doubts arise about the manager’s trustworthiness Changes in the manager’s strategy, staff, or organizational structure"
Fund profiles mentioned
- Abu Dhabi Investment Authority (ADIA): United Arab Emirates
Related questions
- What do sovereign wealth funds look for in private equity managers?
- How does co-investment work between sovereign wealth funds and managers?
- How do NZ Super Fund and the Future Fund work with external managers?
- How do sovereign wealth funds and family offices co-invest?
The sources behind this answer
Frequently asked questions
What manager-level changes cause sovereign funds to consider termination?
The IFSWF notes that changes to a manager's investment strategy, staff departures, and broader organizational changes are reasons to consider termination[1].
Did the NPRF ever cancel an external manager contract due to fee issues?
The NPRF ended its indexed equity mandate with State Street Global Advisors after the UK FCA fined the firm for overcharging clients including the NPRF[2].
Why does the Future Fund find selecting external managers challenging?
The Future Fund aims to be benchmark-unaware and finds it difficult to locate managers who do not focus on benchmarks[4].
Sources
- oslocs1.pdf
- Opening Statement by NTMA Chief Executive John Corrigan to the Committee of Public Accounts, as of February 13, 2014
- Understanding ADIA, Chris Wright Media, as of February 1, 2008
- Australia’s Future Fund Investment Wizardry, as of May 15, 2013
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes SovereignWealthFunds.com. If you are a fund manager, capital raiser or family office and want to talk through how sovereign wealth funds work, reach out to him directly.
- Email: richard@familyoffices.com
- Text: (808) 600-9260
- WhatsApp: (808) 600-9260
Disclaimer
Informational only. SovereignWealthFunds.com is an independent public-source reference. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fund named on it, and it is not investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as of the dates shown next to them and may have changed; please read each fund's official pages, linked on its profile. To report an error, use the contact page. Copyright SovereignWealthFunds.com. All rights reserved.
