How does Norway's fiscal rule limit withdrawals from its fund?
Short answer: Norway's fiscal rule limits government spending over time to the fund's expected real return, which shields the budget from oil revenue volatility[1][2]. The framework protects the fund capital from inflation and preserves it indefinitely by spending only the sustainable long-term average real return rather than volatile annual returns[3][4]. It also provides flexibility by allowing higher spending during economic downturns and lower spending during upturns[1].
Core Spending Limits and Capital Preservation
The fiscal framework is designed to preserve the fund capital indefinitely by spending only the expected real investment returns[3][4]. The rule protects the principal from inflation and uses a long-term average return to deliver steadier revenue to the state budget[3]. By separating government spending from direct oil income, the 1990 Petroleum Fund Act allowed savings to accumulate in the fund over time[5].
The rule has restricted non-oil budget deficits to the fund's expected real return, which has been cited at about 3 percent of fund assets[1][2]. At an earlier point, the framework allowed withdrawals of about 4 percent a year over the economic cycle. A past observation noted that the government spent considerably less than the 4 percent limit[6].
The framework acts as a main pillar of Norwegian economic policy and has held broad cross-party support since its introduction, spanning from the Progress Party to Labour and other left-leaning parties[7][8].
Flexibility and Proposed Alternatives
Annual investment fluctuations do not directly dictate yearly budget spending under the fiscal framework[4]. The rule allows the government to spend more than the average return during economic downturns and less during upturns[1]. For instance, Norway drew on the fund to finance extra costs related to Covid-19[8][9]. In the first half of 2016, Norway withdrew NOK 44.6 billion under the rule.
Alternative approaches have been explored. NBIM proposed an alternative rule that links withdrawals to GDP and the business cycle rather than the total fund value, aiming to lower average withdrawals over time and reduce depletion risks[10]. An analysis by Wulfsberg reported by OsloMet found that, due to compounding, the fund would likely be worth about two-thirds of its initial value in 100 years if the rule remains unchanged[7].
"The Fund's capital shall be maintained for the infinite future and only the real return shall be spent. Since it is set as a long-term average, independently of what is actually achieved in one given year, swings in actual returns have minimal implications for the amount that can be spent over the budget from one year to the next."
Related questions
- How do deposit and withdrawal rules work for the Alaska Permanent Fund?
- How do transfer rules for Kuwait's Future Generations Fund work?
- How does Kuwait split savings between its two funds?
- How do Chile's ESSF and PRF decide on withdrawals?
The sources behind this answer
Frequently asked questions
What is the expected real return limit set by the fiscal rule?
The fiscal rule limits the non-oil deficit to the fund's expected real return, which is about 3 percent of assets, though it was previously set at about 4 percent[1][2].
Does the fiscal rule allow higher spending in emergencies?
Yes, the rule permits higher spending during downturns, and withdrawals were used to finance extra Covid-19 costs[1][8][9].
What alternative rule did NBIM propose?
NBIM proposed tying withdrawals to GDP and the business cycle instead of fund value to lower average spending and lower the risk of depletion[10].
Sources
- Management of revenues - Norwegianpetroleum.no
- A New Fiscal Framework for Resource-Rich Countries, as of November 2023
- InvestorModels.pdf
- From oil to equities
- Egil Matsen: Government Pension Fund Global - experiences and organisation, as of October 30, 2017
- The $870 billion Norwegian model | Corporate Knights, as of December 2, 2014
- The oil fund will not be there for our grandchildren - OsloMet
- Management of the Government Pension Fund Global | Bank for International Settlements, as of October 30, 2020
- Management of the Government Pension Fund Global, as of October 30, 2020
- Norway’s NBIM outlines alternative rule for GPFG withdrawals - European Pensions
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes SovereignWealthFunds.com. If you are a fund manager, capital raiser or family office and want to talk through how sovereign wealth funds work, reach out to him directly.
- Email: richard@familyoffices.com
- Text: (808) 600-9260
- WhatsApp: (808) 600-9260
Disclaimer
Informational only. SovereignWealthFunds.com is an independent public-source reference. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fund named on it, and it is not investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as of the dates shown next to them and may have changed; please read each fund's official pages, linked on its profile. To report an error, use the contact page. Copyright SovereignWealthFunds.com. All rights reserved.
